Sportsmanship and the Rules
Rule 2, Fair Sailing
Rule 30.3, Starting Penalties: Black Flag Rule
Rule 69.1, Allegations of Gross Misconduct:
Action by a Protest Committee
When a boat knows that she has broken the Black Flag rule, she is obliged to retire promptly. When she does not do so and then deliberately hinders another boat in the race, she commits a gross breach of sportsmanship and, therefore, of rule 2, and her helmsman commits a gross breach of sportsmanship.
Summary of the Facts
At the start of race 4, A was clearly about three to four hull lengths on the
course side of the starting line. Rule 30.3 was in effect, so the race committee
disqualified her without a hearing. A, although she knew she was over the line
at her starting signal, continued to race and covered B for the first part of
the first beat. B protested A for breaking rule 2.
The protest committee confirmed the disqualification of A under rule 30.3. It
also decided that, by continuing to race and cover B when she knew that she
had broken rule 30.3, A broke rule 2. As required by rule 90.3(b), it penalized
her by making her disqualification not excludable. Later the same day, acting
under rule 69.1, it called a hearing alleging that the behaviour of A’s
helmsman in hindering B was a gross breach of sportsmanship and of rule 2. It
decided that the helmsman had committed the alleged gross breaches, and excluded
him and disqualified A from all races of the series. A appealed the protest
committee’s decisions.
Decision
A’s appeal is dismissed.
A was correctly disqualified from race 4 for breaking rule 30.3. The protest
committee found as fact that A’s helmsman knew that he had been on the
course side of the starting line at the starting signal; that he had broken
rule 30.3; that he was, therefore, already disqualified; and that he had seriously
hindered another boat in the race. A clearly committed a gross breach of sportsmanship
(see Sportsmanship and the Rules) and of rule 2, and the protest committee acted
properly under rule 69.1 in excluding A’s helmsman and disqualifying A
from all races of the series.
RYA 1984/7